If there is one thing the Chiefs don't mind happening midway through the season, it's the emergence of skill and talent on offense from players who aren't high on the depth chart. The legacy-making game that Emmett Johnson just had against Atlanta and the growth of Cyrus Allen from practice squad prodigy to touchdown-scoring rookie are just two examples of players going above and beyond. One has been more consistent than the other, but both are already contributing heavily in their rookie seasons.
Then you come to Xavier Worthy on the Chiefs' depth chart, sitting right by Rashee Rice at the top of the list. Sadly, if anyone is playing well enough to be called WR2, it's certainly not Worthy. His lack of sideline awareness has been an issue since he entered the league as the 28th overall pick in 2024.
That first year would prove to be Worthy's best so far, racking up 638 receiving yards in the regular season through all 17 games (37.5 yards per game). Those yards paired nicely with six receiving touchdowns, 104 rushing yards, and three rushing touchdowns.
Since then, his play has regressed, he's had a lingering shoulder injury, and the speed that made him such a high-ranking draft pick has not been seen on the field in quite some time. So what do the Chiefs do with him just two and a half seasons into his career?
Worthy's biggest weakness keeps exposing him
Seemingly every week, Worthy makes some mishap on the field that causes all of Chiefs Kingdom to riot and curse his name on social media. His most recent blunder was allowing the Falcons to recover the first successful onside kick of the 2026 season (1-for-23).
you won’t see an onside kick prettier than this. pic.twitter.com/1oSTxR1Hq0
— NFL (@NFL) November 15, 2026
A few weeks before, in Seattle, Worthy was screaming across the field late in the second quarter and was out of bounds by the time the ball reached his position, which ultimately ended in the only pick of the game for Mahomes. Even though the target was Royals, it still stands to reason that if you're in the vicinity of the ball, you should at least try to be in bounds.
The week after that, Worthy was out of bounds again, this time in the end zone in Denver, waiting for a pass from a scrambling Mahomes, who was being chased by three defenders to his right. Last week versus the Jets, he struggled to stay inbounds while Mahomes kept the play alive toward his sideline, where only Worthy was there to make a catch if needed.
In mid-October, Worthy's awareness of the sideline looked different. This time, he caught the ball in bounds, over the middle of the field, and ran out of bounds a good 7–10 yards before he needed to. With minimal time left in the half, it was praised as a good decision by the broadcasters, but after looking at a different angle, it was obvious he could have set Harrison Butker up with a better kick with plenty of time left.
That's all within the last month, with every example showing Worthy's inability to recognize where the sideline is. It was even an issue during training camp earlier this year, after a season full of sideline debacles the year before.
Luckily for Worthy, Andy Reid (and special teams coordinator Dave Toub) are very forgiving coaches, despite fans begging them to start being ruthless. This has been shown by Toub's determination to make Nikko Remigio the star returner until last week, and it's shown by Reid's consistent devotion to Butker despite him missing the most kicks of any kicker over the last two seasons (17).
With a plethora of presents for Mahomes, where does Worthy rank?
The good news is that Mahomes may have finally found a groove with his newly constructed offense around him. Adding Josh Downs this past week, the rookie running back from Nebraska putting a golden stamp on his first NFL start, and a slew of receivers suddenly stepping up have all helped. It feels like Mahomes finally has a plethora of talent at the skill positions for the first time since Tyreek Hill left for Miami.
There has always been hope that Mahomes would gel with multiple receivers and pass-catching backs, whether it be through the Justyn Ross preseason hype videos or bringing in future Hall of Famers like DeAndre Hopkins midseason for a playoff push. But after losing Tyquan Thornton just one month into the season, it appears Mahomes finally has a decent receiving corps.
Which means Worthy's spot on the depth chart could slide, officially. But unofficially, Worthy's spot has already slid this season, and it's becoming more noticeable every week. So where does he rank among his colleagues? And is it low enough that the Chiefs could consider relegating him to gadget plays and special teams?
First, let's look at the depth chart. In the six days since Downs arrived in Kansas City, he has already taken the WR2 position behind Rice at WR1. Downs, in his first game as a Chief, caught four passes on ten snaps for 53 yards and an impressive TD (below). Worthy, in the same game, had zero catches on two targets over the span of 55 snaps.
WELCOME TO THE CHIEFS, @JOSHDOWNS 🤝 pic.twitter.com/Y2yolru6sP
— Kansas City Chiefs (@Chiefs) November 15, 2026
Allen, the rookie out of Cincinnati, is sitting at WR4, just ahead of Jalen Royals, who is still waiting for a breakout game of his own. Then Andrew Armstrong, who made a heck of a first touchdown catch against Atlanta, rounds out the receiving room before Jacob De Jesus and all the injured players (Thornton, Jeff Caldwell, Jimmy Holiday).
Officially, Worthy ranks third-highest on the Chiefs' list of receivers, but Allen is already proving to be a more trustworthy deep threat for Mahomes. He's shown that by getting deep passes in both of the last two games, failing to haul in a would-be touchdown against the Jets and securing his first NFL touchdown against the Falcons.
3rd touchdown pass for Mahomes! Cyrus Allen scores on a 39-yarder.
— NFL (@NFL) November 15, 2026
KCvsATL on CBS/Paramount+
Stream on @NFLPlus pic.twitter.com/Nijm7zG3lT
That means Allen is easily sliding into WR3 as the days go on. Armstrong and Worthy have completely different sizes and skill sets, but by the end of the season, Mahomes might feel more comfortable throwing a 50-50 ball to the 6'4", 210-pound beast rather than the speedy, small guy who might land out of bounds. Moving Armstrong up feels premature, but not impossible when looking toward the future.
But as we know, Mahomes and Reid love their tight ends to catch passes more than block. Which means Worthy is also knocked down the list behind Travis Kelce (obviously) and, one could argue, Noah Gray.
Gray currently has 190 receiving yards on 16 receptions (11.9 ypc) with an 80% catch percentage. Compare that to Worthy catching 33 passes for 278 yards (8.4 ypc) with only a 66% catch rate. Put it all together, and it's easy to see why Mahomes might trust Gray more than Worthy when he needs a play, especially right at the sticks on third or fourth down.
With Rice, Downs, Allen, Kelce, Gray, and Thornton all above him, it's apparent that Worthy might not be targeted or favored as often by Mahomes as the team rolls on. That rings especially true after Johnson's massive game against Atlanta, which followed a Jets matchup that showed Johnson's ability to get open and use his speed.
Wrap it all up with the return of Kenneth Walker III within the next two games (hopefully), and it's almost like Worthy has been pushed off the field, where he would likely already be standing awaiting a pass.
What does Andy Reid have to say about it?
After such a disappointing day on Sunday, following three mediocre weeks in a row, Reid was asked about Worthy and his lack of production on Tuesday.
"He just needs to keep doing his thing and working and he'll be fine. Some days will be his, and some days it just goes to other guys. That's just how this thing works. We're spreading it around. Pat loves spreading it around. he does a great job with it. Our coaches love doing that. It's tough on defenses, so everybody's kind of getting a little piece of the pie. You saw when he was only the guy against the Chargers and his production there was great. So it's not as if he's not capable of it."
While Reid always provides a masterclass in "coach speak," this reinforces the idea that Mahomes and Reid are going to look toward other receivers more and more often. "Spreading it around" is going to mean more snaps for more receivers and more targets for newer, less mistake-prone players.
The game Reid references, the Chargers game from Week 6, was definitely Worthy's best game of the year. He caught all seven targets for 73 yards, including a 19-yard gain that set up Butker's 50-yard field goal before the half.
Sadly, that 73-yard performance was tied for fifth-most in Worthy's career up to this point, a career that many Chiefs fans thought would be filled to the brim with better games than that.
So what can K.C. actually do with Worthy?
It's obvious that Mahomes and Reid have a Worthy problem. Whether they choose to address it or not is up to them. The only way Reid seems to show his displeasure with players, usually because of their constant on- and off-the-field issues, is to take snaps away. And the only way Mahomes seems to show it is to stop targeting you, much like he did with Kadarius Toney early in 2024.
Reid has already shown his approach this year when he benched Kingsley Suamataia earlier this season, and he's shown it before when running backs have fumbling issues and their snap counts get reduced for the rest of the game.
But Worthy is a first-round pick and someone that GM Brett Veach and Reid have voiced their optimism about, so he's not going to just vanish from the depth chart. Instead, what Kansas City should contemplate is moving Worthy back to returning punts while Downs slowly learns to play the role Worthy was brought in to play.
Worthy has only returned one punt in the NFL, back in December of last season, but during his last season at Texas, he led all of D1 football in punt return yards (371) while also leading the SEC in punt returns (22) and return touchdowns (one). The two years prior weren't bad either, with one seeing him return 15 punts for 146 yards (9.7 ypr) and his freshman season seeing him return three for 47 (15.7 ypr).
With Remigio gone to Houston, Brashard Smith on the injury report, Allen ascending in the offense, and Downs coming to town to seemingly replace Worthy ... it all makes sense. Relegating Worthy to punt returns and minimizing his offensive snap counts to make way for younger, less mistake-prone players is the best way to begin Worthy's smaller role on the team.
It's happened with plenty of receivers before him. Reid got tired of Kadarius Toney's mistakes on the field, effectively benched him, and then won a Super Bowl. Most recently, it was Mecole Hardman who went from return specialist to speedy, somewhat reliable receiver, then was relegated and eventually dropped before returning to the team on a one-year deal, only to return punts once again. Basically, this would not be new for Reid and this coaching staff.
Other than return plays, he can obviously still be used for gadget plays, trick sets, sweeps, and those famously tricky plays that Reid has countless drawings of in his playbook.
No matter which way one looks at it, it would appear Worthy is on a downward slide, watching young guns below him on the depth chart see more targets farther down the field. He's seeing running backs and players who have only been on the team for a week be used in the exact manner he was drafted to become fluent in. He's seeing plenty of "motivation" online after every game, especially from some of the more toxic fans of Chiefs Kingdom, and it would appear it's not working to make him any better.
Sometimes the front office just has to manage around a player it put so much effort and so many resources into, wearing egg on its face while Mahomes makes it look good for drafting the up-and-comers.
