Skip to main content

The 20 greatest individual seasons in Kansas City Chiefs history

ByBransen Gibson
Priest Holmes had some legendary years with the Kansas City Chiefs, but did he have the greatest season in team history?
Priest Holmes had some legendary years with the Kansas City Chiefs, but did he have the greatest season in team history? | Jeff Gross/GettyImages

When you think back on the history of the Kansas City Chiefs, which player do you think had the greatest one season in team history?

From unstoppable rushers to unblockable pass rushers, from defenders you wouldn’t throw the ball anywhere near to quarterbacks who could throw the ball everywhere, there have been some incredible performances that rewrote the record books and shaped the future of a franchise.

But which was the best of them all? I delved into the chapters of Chiefs' history to rank my top 20 seasons the Chiefs have ever seen.

Honorable mentions:

There are some incredible players who had fantastic seasons that I couldn’t quite fit into my top 20. 

Offensive linemen like Willie Roaf, Will Shields, Mitchell Schwartz, Brian Waters, and Ed Budde are all Chiefs legends, but it is hard to quantify the absence of something (in this case, sacks) to measure against other feats in a specific season. 

The lack of historic pass-blocking data compared to what we have today makes it practically impossible, which is why none of those players feature despite being amongst the best Chiefs players ever. Slotting them into the list felt like a guess, and I didn’t think that was fair.

I won’t spoil it by telling you who, but two of the franchise’s biggest icons are also notably absent from my list. It’s not that I don’t consider them all-time greats; I just don’t think they had one specific season that ranks as one of the best 20 ever. Maybe you agree, or maybe you don’t. It’s okay either way.

20. Abner Haynes, RB - 1960

Abner Haynes might be the most surprising and least recognizable player on this list, but it’s time to put some respect on his name.

Haynes was the first person in franchise history to win a league MVP award back in 1960, and until Patrick Mahomes won it in 2018, he was the only MVP this franchise had ever had.

A halfback and return specialist, Haynes was an original Dallas Texan and part of the first team in franchise history in 1960, catching a touchdown in the team's first-ever game.

He was the AFL’s leader in rushing yards (875), touchdowns (nine), punt return yards (215) and all-purpose yards (2100), that season and he led the Texans with 1,451 yards from scrimmage and 12 total touchdowns.

Haynes was named the AFL’s most valuable player and Rookie of the Year, and he was first-team All-Pro and an All-Star as well. His numbers might look small by today's standards, but they were among the best at the time, and as one of only two MVPs in franchise history, He belongs on the list.

19. Albert Lewis, CB - 1989

Albert Lewis was one of the best cornerbacks in Chiefs history, and of his 11 seasons in Kansas City, his 1989 campaign stands out as his best.

Lewis was first-team All-Pro for the first time that year thanks to his four interceptions, two forced fumbles, 57 tackles, and one sack. He also had a career-high 35 passes defended.

Lewis had other seasons with more interceptions—he had eight in 1985 and six in 1993—and he was the team MVP in 1986, but 1989 was his best season in a four-year stretch that saw him named to four Pro Bowls and first-team All-Pro twice, which is why I have it higher on my list.

According to Pro Football Reference (PFR), Lewis also had an approximate value of 19 that season, the highest of his career. Approximate Value is a score PFR has put on every player’s season in NFL history to try, and quantify how impactful a player they were. The higher the number, the better. LaDainian Tomlinson is PFR’s all-time AV leader with a score of 26 in 2006.

18. Otis Taylor, WR - 1966

Otis Taylor became the first person in franchise history to have a 1,000-yard receiving season when he eclipsed that benchmark with the Chiefs in 1966.

Taylor had 58 catches for 1,297 yards and eight touchdowns that year, with his 22.4 yards per catch and longest reception of 89 yards both leading the AFL. He was a Pro Bowler and first-team All-Pro that year. It was the most receiving yards Taylor had in a season in his career, and he still sits third in Chiefs history for all-time receiving yards with 7,306.

It’s difficult to compare Taylor’s feats from the '60s and '70s to modern accomplishments, but Pro Football Reference (PFR) gave Taylor’s season an approximate value of 20, tied for the third-highest mark by any Chiefs player ever.

17. Abner Haynes, RB - 1962

Abner Haynes, again! If you hadn't hear of him before, you definitely have now.

While Haynes won the AFL MVP in 1960, his third season in 1962 was the best of his career. He led the league in yards from scrimmage (1,622), total touchdowns (19) and rushing touchdowns (13) with the Texans and also had 1,049 yards on the ground to become the first 1,000-yard rusher in franchise history.

Haynes had a career-high four 100-yard rushing games that season, including a 164-yard, two-touchdown game against the Buffalo Bills in Week 4, the most yards he ever had on the ground in a game. In the playoffs, Haynes had both a touchdown catch and a TD pass in the ‘62 AFL Championship game, helping the Texans to a 20-17 double-overtime win over the Houston Oilers.

PFR gave his season an aproximate value of 20, higher than his MVP performance two years earlier.

16. Emmitt Thomas, CB - 1974

What a year 1974 was for Emmitt Thomas. He was tied for the most touchdown receptions on the team that year. That sounds fair on the surface, but it’s incredible when you consider that he was a cornerback.

Thomas had 12 interceptions for the season, two of which he took back to the house, including a 73-yard return in the final game of the season. He had two games with two picks, and his dozen interceptions, two return touchdowns, and 214 return yards were all the most in the league that year as well.

He was a first-team All-Pro and Pro Bowler that year.

15. Harrison Butker, K- 2023

In 2023, we witnessed the greatest season by a kicker in Kansas City Chiefs history and possibly the greatest season by an NFL kicker ever.

Harrison Butker was near perfect in 2023, helping kick the Chiefs to back-to-back Super Bowl victories and the team’s third Lombardi Trophy in five years.

Butker made 33 of 35 field goals that season, including going five-for-five from 50+ yards, and he was a perfect 38-for-38 on extra points as well.

Crucially for the Chiefs, Butker’s red-hot form carried over into the playoffs. He made every single kick he attempted in the postseason, nailing all 11 field goals and all eight extra points.

And on the biggest stage of all, he stood up under pressure. Butker was four-for-four on field goals in the Super Bowl, hitting the longest field goal in Super Bowl history and making the game-tying kick as time expired to send the game to overtime.

Butker missed just two kicks for the entire season, including the playoffs, going 90-for-92 (97.8 percent overall). His 94.3 field goal percentage during the regular season is the second-highest in team history.

14. Priest Holmes< RB - 2001

Spoiler alert: Priest Holmes is a name that is going to appear on this list more than once.

2001 was Holmes’s first season in Kansas City after signing as a free agent from the Baltimore Ravens, and he made an immediate impact with his new team.

Holmes won the rushing title with 1,555 yards that season, setting what was then a Chiefs record for the most rushing yards and becoming the first-ever undrafted player to lead the league in that category.

He had 614 yards as a pass catcher too, and his 2,169 total yards were also the most in the NFL that season – not bad for a player who was signed for an average of just $1.69 million a year.

Holmes earned his first first-team All-Pro and Pro Bowl selections that year, kicking off a golden three-year span that was one of the most dominant stretches by any player in NFL history.

13. Dante Hall - 2003

You don’t earn a nickname like “the human joystick” by accident, and in 2003, Dante Hall showcased why he is regarded as one of the best returners the NFL has ever seen.

Hall made NFL history that year with Kansas City, becoming the first player ever to have multiple kick return touchdowns and multiple punt return touchdowns in the same season.

Hall ran a punt or a kick to the house in back-to-back-to-back-to-back games from Week 2 to Week 5, becoming the first and still only player to have a return touchdown in four-straight games.

The best of the lot came against the Denver Broncos. Hall caught a punt inside the 10, reversed direction twice while dodging Broncos tacklers, then ran 93 yards downfield for a touchdown. It was his seventh return TD in a 10-game span.

Hall also had a kick return touchdown in the playoffs that season against the Indianapolis Colts. He had five total return touchdowns that year, which is still the most by a Chiefs player ever in one season, and was named as the All-Pro returner.

12. Chris Jones, DT - 2022

The Chiefs have been blessed with some legendary pass rushers throughout their history. Chris Jones is one of them, and his 2022 season is right up there among the best of the best.

Jones had 15.5 sacks that season, an equal career-best and a stunning number for a defensive tackle. His sack total, 29 quarterback hits, and 17 tackles for loss were all team highs that season, and he had two forced fumbles, four pass deflections, and 44 total tackles as well.

In the AFC Championship game against the Cincinnati Bengals that season, Jones had five quarterback hits, three tackles for loss, and two sacks, one of which ended the potential go-ahead drive for the Bengals late in the fourth quarter and helped set the Chiefs up for the eventual game-winning field goal.

Jones had a career-best five multi-sack games across the regular season and playoffs combined. He was both a first-team All-Pro and a Pro Bowler, and he finished third in Defensive Player of the Year voting.

11. Jamaal Charles, RB - 2013

Growing up, seeing Jamaal Charles on the field in 2013 was the first time I remember recognizing that what a player was doing was something really special.

Charles had a career-high 1,980 yards from scrimmage, leading the Chiefs in both rushing yards (1,287) and receiving yards (693) while also scoring the most rushing touchdowns (12) and total touchdowns (19) in the NFL.

Of the 15 games Charles played, he had 100 yards or more from scrimmage in 13 of them and at least one touchdown in 12. He also led the Chiefs, including wide receivers, in p yards per game

The highlight of his season came in Week 16 when Charles had one of the most remarkable games by a running back ever. He had eight catches for 195 yards and four touchdowns, ending with 215 total yards and five total touchdowns on the day. 

Those bonkers numbers scored him 59.50 fantasy points, a record that still stands as the most by any player in a single game. Charles was named both a first-team All-Pro and a Pro Bowler, and he finished third in Offensive Player of the Year voting.

10. Tyreek Hill, WR - 2018

The league had already caught glimpses of what Tyreek Hill was capable of in his first two years in the NFL, but his third season in 2018 was when the Cheetah really burst onto the scene.

Hill had 169 receiving yards, two touchdown catches, and a 97-yard punt return to the house in the season opener, setting the tone for the stellar season that was to come.

He had six games of 100+ yards or more, including 215 yards and two touchdowns in a Monday Night Football shootout against the Los Angeles Rams, on his way to setting the record for the most receiving yards in franchise history with 1,479.

Hill had 12 touchdown catches for the year and 151 rushing yards and one touchdown run as well that season, while also leading the team in receiving yards and receiving touchdowns. 

Hill's speed made him the perfect big-play target, and he had the most 20+ yard receptions in the NFL that season. He was a first-team All-Pro and Pro Bowler as well.

9. Larry Johnson, RB - 2006

After a half-season as a starter showed the type of potential Larry Johnson was capable of in 2005, the Chiefs made him their workhorse in 2006. Work. Horse.

Kansas City handed Johnson the ball 416 times, giving him the punishing record for the most carries by a running back in a season ever in NFL history. In contrast, Kenneth Walker has never had more than 230 rushing attempts in a season in his career.

Johnson feasted, breaking Kansas City’s single-season rushing record with 1,789 yards, besting the previous high Johnson himself set in 2005 and a record that still stands to this day. It was the second-most yards in the NFL that year.

Overall, Johnson averaged 111.8 yards per game on the ground and had 410 yards receiving and 2,199 total yards—all career highs. He also had 19 total touchdowns, 17 of which were on the ground.  Johnson was both a first-team All-Pro and a Pro Bowler that year.

It was a fantastic season, but the sheer number of carries and lower yards per attempt have 2006 slightly behind one of Johnson’s other years on my list.

8. Justin Houston, DE - 2014

Justin Houston was unstoppable in 2014, turning in the best season of his career and one of the best by a pass rusher in NFL history.

Houston was a nightmare for opposing linemen, recording an eye-popping 22 sacks, which was the most in the league that season and the most ever by a Kansas City Chief.

Heading into the final game of the season, Houston needed three sacks to break Derrick Thomas’s previous team record. He got four, writing his name into the history books and finishing just half a sack shy of the all-time NFL record.

Houston had sacks in six straight games twice during the season, and there were only three games all year in which he didn’t have at least one. He ended the year with a career-high 69 combined tackles and 25 tackles for loss as well as four forced fumbles, justifiably earning both All-Pro and Pro Bowl selections.

Given that Houston played an extra game because of the longer season than Thomas did in 1990 and his record-breaking sacks came in that extra game, I have him just behind Thomas on my list.

7. Derrick Thomas, LB – 1990

Derrick Thomas re-wrote the record books during a phenomenal 1990 season with Kansas City.

In just his second year in the NFL, the legendary linebacker recorded 20.0 sacks that season, setting what was a franchise record at the time and becoming the first Chief ever to reach the 20-sack mark.

More than a third of those sacks came in one game alone. Thomas terrorised the Seattle Seahawks’ offensive line and quarterback Dave Krieg when he had an NFL-record seven sacks during their Week 10 matchup, including a forced fumble in the end zone that resulted in a touchdown.

It was one of six forced fumbles Thomas had that year, and he ended the season with 65 total tackles, 35 QB pressures, and two fumble recoveries. He was named an All-Pro that year, and he finished second in the Defensive Player of the Year voting as well. 

Thomas’s seven-sack game still stands as the most in a game by a single player, and his team sack record stood for 24 years before it was broken by Houston in 2014.

Setting two sack records in the same season and having one fewer game played is what has Thomas ahead of Houston on my list.

6. Larry Johnson, RB - 2005

Imagine going from having Priest Homes, a running back who had possibly the greatest three-year stretch at the position ever, and then handing the ball off to his replacement, who was arguably even better.

That’s exactly what happened when Larry Johnson took over the starting job for Kansas City midway through the 2005 season.

Johnson had 399 yards in his first eight games before exploding in the back half. He averaged an insane 150 yards per game for the rest of the year, rushing for 100+ yards every game and ending with a then-Chiefs-record 1,750 yards for the season, despite starting just nine games.

His biggest game of the year came in Week 10 when Johnson had 211 yards and two touchdowns in a win over the Houston Texans, which was the most yards by a Chiefs halfback in a game at the time. He also had 201 yards and three touchdowns in Week 17 against the Cincinnati Bengals.

Overall, Johnson had 20 rushing touchdowns, 99 rushing first downs, 336 carries, and 2,093 total yards, earning Pro Bowl and second-team All-Pro honors.

It was an incredible season made all the more impressive by the fact that it was really only half a season. Johnson’s numbers in 2006 were higher, but this stands as a more remarkable season in my books.

5. Travis Kelce, TE - 2020

It was the greatest season from a tight end of all time by a player who deserves to go down as the greatest tight end of all time. The 2020 version of Travis Kelce was something different.

Kelce set an NFL record for the most receiving yards by a tight end in the history of the game that season, racking up a ridiculous 1,416 yards in 15 games.

He had 105 receptions for the year to become the first TE to have 100+ catches more than once, 11 touchdowns, and he had career-highs in yards per game (94.4) and yards per reception (13.5).

As good as Kelce was in the regular season, he was even better in the playoffs. 

Kelce had 100+ yards in all three postseason games, and he set the record for the most yards by a TE in Super Bowl history with 133 yards in the loss to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. His 10 catches and 33-yard reception were also game-highs in the Super Bowl.

Overall, Kelce had 1,776 yards, 136 catches, nine games of 100+ yards, and 14 touchdowns in the regular season and playoffs combined, making it the most prolific season by a tight end ever.

4. Patrick Mahomes, QB - 2022

For me, 2022 was the year Patrick Mahomes set himself apart from some of the other great quarterbacks of the 21st century and proved that the Chiefs weren’t a one-hit wonder.

With MVP, Super Bowl, and Super Bowl MVP titles already under his belt, Mahomes accomplished all three in one season in 2022. Mahomes had a career-high 5,250 passing yards alongside 41 passing touchdowns, 79.0 QBR and 54.6 success rate – all of which led the NFL.

In the playoffs, Mahomes threw seven touchdowns, zero interceptions, and had an average passer rating of 114.7. 

Mahomes won the “Burrowhead” AFC Championship revenge game against the Cincinnati Bengals, then in the Super Bowl, he had two touchdown passes and just one incompletion in the second half and a crucial 26-yard run late in the game to set up the winning field goal against the Philadelphia Eagles.

It was a legacy-defining season for Mahomes. He became just the third quarterback to win multiple regular-season and Super Bowl MVPs and the first ever to have the most passing yards, passing touchdowns, and to win both MVPs in the same season.

The season cemented Mahomes as an all-time great, but it wasn’t quite as good as the season where his legend first began in my books.

3. Priest Homes, RB - 2003

Priest Holmes was a record-setting machine for Kansas City, but the one he accomplished in 2003 was something nobody had done in more than 80 years of professional football.

Holmes ran for 27 touchdowns that year, with his two scores in the final game of the season setting new NFL records for the most rushing touchdowns and the most total touchdowns by any player in a single season.

It capped off an incredible season when Holmes was at the peak of his powers. He ended the year with 1,420 rushing yards and a career-high 690 receiving yards (2,110 yards from scrimmage).

It was the second year in a row that Holmes had 20+ touchdowns, making him one of just two players to accomplish that feat alongside Emmitt Smith. Holmes found the end zone in 13 of his 16 games that season, and he had four games with three TDs. He was named first-team All-Pro and a Pro Bowler for the third year in a row.

Holmes’ rushing touchdown record was equaled, and his total touchdown record was broken by Seattle Seahawk Shaun Alexander two years later, before LaDainian Tomlinson (28 rushing touchdowns, 31 total touchdowns) set the current record in 2006.

2. Priest Holmes, RB - 2002

2003 was an incredible season for Priest Holmes, but in my opinion, the season he had the year prior was even better.

Holmes led the NFL with 2,287 total yards, 24 total touchdowns and 105 first downs, breaking his own record for what was the most rushing yards in Chiefs history at the time set the year prior with 1,615 yards.

Incredibly, Holmes put up those numbers in just 14 games after a hip injury sidelined him for the last two weeks of the year.

Holmes had four touchdowns in the first game of the season against the Cleveland Browns and 307 total yards—197 rushing and 110 receiving—against the Seattle Seahawks in Week 12, the second-most yards in a game ever by a Chief.

Holmes was the second player ever to score 14 touchdowns in the first seven games of a season that year, averaged 115.4 rushing yards per game, had 100+ yards from scrimmage in every game bar one, and his 21 rushing touchdowns were more than he’d had in his first five seasons in the league combined.

He won the Offensive Player of the Year award, finished fourth in MVP voting and was a first-team All Pro and Pro Bowler.

1. Patrick Mahomes, QB - 2018

This was the season Patrick Mahomes single-handedly changed the fate of a franchise and reshaped the entire NFL.

After one appearance as a rookie, Mahomes inherited the starting job in his second season in 2018 and immediately did things nobody had ever seen on a football field before. His first career touchdown pass at Arrowhead was a sign of things to come.

The cross-body throws, the scrambles that became touchdowns, the throws on the run, the left-handed pass, the deep bombs, the no-look pass, the two six-touchdown games, the funky arm angles—all of it was incredible.

Mahomes threw for 5,097 yards and 50 touchdowns that season, both Chiefs records at the time, with the latter still standing today. He won the MVP and Offensive Player of the Year awards and was named first-team All-Pro.

It was the kind of season Chiefs fans never thought they’d see from a player better than they ever could have imagined. It gave a glimpse of what was to come for the Chiefs and showcased the greatness Mahomes was capable of for the first time. It was also the greatest season ever by a Kansas City Chiefs player.

Add us as a preferred source on Google