Chiefs Draft Picks Done Right

Home » Chiefs » Chiefs Draft Picks Done Right

As much as I want to, I figured you guys probably didn’t want to listen to me rant about the CBA again this week. And since the “7 holy days” agreement is reasonably promising, it seems fair to spare the billionaire tyrants my wrath for a day.

Like many of you, I’m starting to lick my chops in anticipation of the upcoming draft. But I’m no Mel Kiper. The way I handle the draft is to become extremely attached to a handful of players based on dubious logic and snap-judgements. There are usually about ten guys I really want, and ten guys I really don’t, and we don’t pick any of them. It’s a personal roller-coaster that I have a really good time with, but I’m under no illusions that I’m actually able to accurately judge between one prospect and the next. I can get the obvious stuff right, thats about it. For expert draft coverage, go to Merlin and Adam, or as I all them, Merl Kiper and Toren McShay (right?).

Draft season always makes me think of our past drafts. I’m somewhat of a Chiefs draft historian. I might not be able to predict who we pick, but I can sure as hell remember them. Name a year, name a round, and I can tell you who we picked. A fairly worthless skill, big picture. It turns out people aren’t really interested in when Montique Sharpe and Willie Pile were drafted*. It is only during draft season, when mentally compiling charts of our previous years’ picks and tendencies, that my memorization becomes at all usefull.

*7th round 2003. We had 2 seventh rounders that year. Cha-ching!

I thought this week I’d consult my mental database and see who checks in as our best picks of the last ten years. Of course this is all subjective. But the common perception is that the Chiefs have been terrible drafters for most of the last decade. And thats true, pretty much. I’ve been saying for years you could staff a Burger King with our defensive tackle busts (Downing would be manager). But there have been some pretty great picks in there too. Here are the ten I’ve deeemed best:

10) Jarrad Page 7th round, 2006- Page’s Chiefs career ended with a whimper rather than a roar due to the ridiculous advice he was getting from his brother/agent. In the end, he got the trade he wanted (to the Patriots. Weird, right?), and he’ll probably hang around the league another few years. Page isn’t anything special, and he never really was.

Still, when a 7th round pick starts 39 games for you, he was a good pick. And Page made some memorable plays for us, usually at the expense of the Raiders. That’s got to count for something.

9) Jimmy Wilkerson 6th round, 2003- Again, not a world-beater. But again, a very late pick. The Chiefs were stupid to let Wilkerson go when they did. And to think it was to make room for the worst defensive line in NFL history. “Sorry Jimmy, I’d give you a ride, but I’ve got Tank Tyler in here….”

Wilkerson went on to record 5 sacks in 2008 and 6 in 2009. His ability to get to the QB was something some of us (Big Matt, Whitlock) recognized while he was still in KC. It’s also something we could’ve really used in 2008 when we shattered the record for least sacks in a season. Ah well, it was still a good pick.

8 ) Dwayne Bowe 1st round, 2007- Bowe was a first-round pick, so he was supposed to be good. But even first-round receivers don’t usually develop into Pro Bowlers. If we can make a playoff run in the next few years Bowe may well go down as the best receiver in Chiefs history. The rest of that draft class was garbage, but my man D-Bowe was a great pick.

7) Tamba Hali 1st round, 2006- Everything I said about Bowe, but a little more awesome. Hali has developed into one of the best pass rushers in the league. I liked the pick at the time, but if you’d told me he would develop into a 15-sack player I’d have been ecstatic. 42 sacks in his first five seasons. Tamba could retire tommorow and he still would’ve been a good pick.

Since we franchised Tamba, you can all look forward to another “Clark Hunt is cheap” article during the next round of contract negotiations.

6) Brandon Carr 5th round, 2008- Carr has played second fiddle to Brandon Flowers ever since they came into the league. He isn’t a fan favorite, and he doesn’t seem to be a Pioli favorite if we can judge by the Arenas pick. But he’s a good player and we got him at a great price. He’s a building block. A steal in the fifth round.

5) Tony Moeaki 3rd round, 2010- I know this is premature, but I couldn’t help myself. I foresee a great destiny for Moeaki. The force is strong with this one. Everybody hyped McCluster, but its our new Tony who will help our offense take that next step forward.

I know a lot of you want to see us take a receiver with our first pick, but I think Moeaki’s presence might make that unnecessary. He can be the #2 threat opposite Bowe. We definitely need depth at receiver, but we don’t necessarily need a stud. I think a second our third round pick would be a wiser move there. Someone to come up alongside Moeaki.

In any case, the trade up to get him at the end of the third was a nice move. A potentially franchise-altering move. WAR Pioli!

4) Scott Fujita 5th round, 2002- People always remember the 2002 draft for Ryan Sims. Understandable. But here we are nine years later and Scott Fujita is still starting and playing well. The guy has had a hell of a career. And he’s not done yet. Something tells me I’ll be seeing him on TV for another 3 years at least.

I felt really good about this draft class after the season. Fujita looked solid, Eddie Freeman had made four sacks, and Ryan Sims had been injured, but was not yet a bust. I thought those three would lead a defensive renaissance in Kansas City. It didn’t happen. But Fujita in the fifth was still one of the greatest steals in Chiefs draft history. Too bad we traded him for another fifth a few years later. This guy should’ve grown old here. But hey, we had to make room for Kendrell Bell (nickname Poop Scoop).

3) Brandon Flowers 2nd round, 2008- Flowers was picked high in the second round, so it might seem odd I have him so high up this list while Hali and Bowe, better players, rank much lower. And its true, Flowers at 35th might not be the third best value pick of the decade. But this pick has always had a special place in my heart. Flowers fell due to a slow 40 time. We were smart enough to see past that. After watching the Chiefs get outsmarted for years, it was nice to see us outsmart everyone else for once. In 2008, I needed that.

2) Jamaal Charles 3rd round, 2008- I remember a post-draft g-chat with Chris Thorman that year where I was complaining about some of our picks, per Big Matt usual. Thorman replied “you had to like the Charles pick though right?” and I admitted, somewhat grudgingly, that it was a good pick. Little did I know just how good it was. Our coach still doesn’t.

Best running back in the NFL in the third round? Shwing!

1) Jared Allen 4th round, 2004- Allen had a down year, if you can call it that. Only 11 sacks and three turnovers created. He has 83 sacks, 22 forced fumbles, 11 fumble recoveries, 4 interceptions and 38 passes defensed in seven years. Remarkable totals. To get a player like that in the fourth round was a stroke of extremely good fortune. Either that or Carl Peterson was actually a draft guru and was just clownin’ with most of his other picks.

In any case, Allen is #1 on my list, no question. And even in death (being traded), he provided us new life. For from that trade Jamaal Charles was born. Circle Of Life.

What say you, Addicts? Any snubs on this list? And was Moeaki our best pick of the 2010 draft?

Never miss a chance to get your fix! Follow Arrowhead Addict on Twitter and be sure to like our Facebook page.

Tags: brandon carr, Brandon Flowers, Dwayne Bowe, Jamaal Charles, jared allen, tamba hali, Tony Moeaki

The Centaur

are you using wilkerson as a way to motivate derrick johnson? i realize draft position is a factor, but i think one of those guys (jimmy, page...jimmy page?) should be bounced in favor of johnson. i find it interesting that wilkerson and kawika mitchell are both on the saints, who up until last year had fujita.

share flag

spam
offensive
disagree
off topic

Big Matt

DJ is certainly a better player than Page and Wilkie, but I don't see him as a better pick. Honestly, there are a few more picks I would've ranked higher than him. Bowe, Flowers and Hali all made the list, sure, but all are significantly better than DJ and were picked later. To me, DJ seems like a guy whose value is about what a 15th pick should be. I like him, glad we picked him, but was it a great pick? I don't know man, he fell into our lap and then underacheived. I wouldn't call that one of the 10 best picks of the decade for us. Of course I guess its all about personal criteria. Ours may be different on this one. I feel bad for both Wilkerson and Mitchell. Both should've gotten the opportunity to become a full-time, multi-year starter somehwere, and neither ever eally did. I feel like the Chiefs' idiocy is to blame for that.

blockeater

For the sake of discussion (argument) I'd say that from this year's draft, Kendrick Lewis showed better bang for our buck (5th rounder) than Moeaki. Moeaki had a great season and only missed a couple games, but Lewis looked pretty solid. I tend to agree we don't need a top guy at WR, but I don't think a latter round is all we need. If we are going to take a WR in the latter rounds, then I hope we address it in free agency with a good talent. I don't need a Larry Fitz (although that would be nice) but a guy better than Urban, Cambers, Engram, Wade, etc. I want a solid receiver in the middle of their career. Is that too much to ask for? I'd also say that any list has to include one or both of our kickers. Succop as Mr. Irrelevant is great especially after we watched us draft Medlock instead of Mason Crosby in 2007. That really turned out well. Although 3rd round for a punter is fairly high, we didn't miss with Colquitt. He will be our punter for his entire career if we are lucky. He is one of the top 5 in the league in my opinion.

I think Moeaki will far outshine Lewis when its all said and done. I'm looking at Lewis right now as another Jarrad Page. That's my most likely comp, anyway. Culquitt is good, but no way is a punter in the third round one of our best picks of the decade. I'm fine with the pick. Liked it at the time, like it now. But if you're picking a punter in the third round, he damn well better be one of the better punters in the league. Similar story with succop, really. If you draft a kicker, he should be ppretty good. Is Succop? He might be. Or he might just be average or even worse. We saw very little of him this year. He doesn't seem to have that big leg we heard about, I'll say that. re: receiver I agree with you, a late round pick at receiver isn't enough. Any time anyone says we can address our need at _____ in the later rounds they're crazy. Late round picks represent flyers and lottery tickets, not needs addressed. I don't consider 2nd or 3rd the later rounds though. Thats where I want a WR.

I just kind of glossed over the fact that you picked Moeaki out of potential rather than what he did this year. I would agree on future success. My point was just about performance this year which doesn't really matter in this discussion. I still think we need more in our receiving corps than just a 2nd or 3rd rounder.

You're probably right. But if we use a 2nd or 3rd rounder and then through free agency bring in a passable #3 receiver who can masquerade as a #2, I'll be fine with that. I wonder if we're even going to get that much, frankly.

njh1491

I have to also go with Berry for 2010. Hopefully he helps lead what will actually be a defensive renaissance. I have always liked Carr and hope hes the next person to get a contract after Tamba. Like all the picks, pretty cool most of them are still here.

KCCHIEFSADDICT

Best pick of the 2010 draft as of right now has to be eric berry for the way he played in 2010 but if moakei seems to progress like it seems he will he will have been the best pick.

I almost included Berry. Ended up shying away at the last second. It's hard for a top 5 pick to overacheive, really. although I certainly think Berry was a better pick than Dorsey, I'll say that.

are you using wilkerson as a way to motivate derrick johnson? i realize draft position is a factor, but i think one of those guys (jimmy, page...jimmy page?) should be bounced in favor of johnson.

i find it interesting that wilkerson and kawika mitchell are both on the saints, who up until last year had fujita.

I feel bad for both Wilkerson and Mitchell. Both should've gotten the opportunity to become a full-time, multi-year starter somehwere, and neither ever eally did. I feel like the Chiefs' idiocy is to blame for that.

I tend to agree we don't need a top guy at WR, but I don't think a latter round is all we need. If we are going to take a WR in the latter rounds, then I hope we address it in free agency with a good talent. I don't need a Larry Fitz (although that would be nice) but a guy better than Urban, Cambers, Engram, Wade, etc. I want a solid receiver in the middle of their career. Is that too much to ask for?

I'd also say that any list has to include one or both of our kickers. Succop as Mr. Irrelevant is great especially after we watched us draft Medlock instead of Mason Crosby in 2007. That really turned out well.

Although 3rd round for a punter is fairly high, we didn't miss with Colquitt. He will be our punter for his entire career if we are lucky. He is one of the top 5 in the league in my opinion.

I think Moeaki will far outshine Lewis when its all said and done. I'm looking at Lewis right now as another Jarrad Page. That's my most likely comp, anyway.

Culquitt is good, but no way is a punter in the third round one of our best picks of the decade. I'm fine with the pick. Liked it at the time, like it now. But if you're picking a punter in the third round, he damn well better be one of the better punters in the league.

Similar story with succop, really. If you draft a kicker, he should be ppretty good. Is Succop? He might be. Or he might just be average or even worse. We saw very little of him this year. He doesn't seem to have that big leg we heard about, I'll say that.

re: receiver

I agree with you, a late round pick at receiver isn't enough. Any time anyone says we can address our need at _____ in the later rounds they're crazy. Late round picks represent flyers and lottery tickets, not needs addressed. I don't consider 2nd or 3rd the later rounds though. Thats where I want a WR.