NOTE TO CHIEFS: DON’T GO TACKLE WITH #5 OVERALL

by Chiefs

Plucking grass out of his facemask for the nth time, the Chiefs’ franchise quarterback Matt Cassel seemed downright pissed off at Brandon Albert, or Rudy Niswanger, or Mike Goff, or any of the countless lineman that let him down as the season progressed. Being driven into the turf is a way of life in the NFL, but there was no earthly reason that defensive lineman should have been able to freely beat Cassel as if candy was about to fall out.

For the first eight weeks of the season the poor guy probably woke up in the middle of the night in a cold sweat, sceaming “NDUKWE!!,” which is hard enough to say, let alone sleep-shout.

As we rebuild this team, perhaps no task is more important than making sure that Cassel is protected better in the upcoming season than he was over the course of a brutal 2009 campaign. I understand that, hell I think virtually every Chiefs fan agrees with that fact.

But please, Scott. Please, please, please, please please please, PLEASE, PLEASE, please don’t even think about drafting an offensive tackle fifth overall.

Don’t entertain the idea. Don’t even allow the idea to exist. Question the very existence of all reality should that idea be presented to you. If Jesus Christ Himself walks through your office door, and says My lamb, Bruce Campbell doth haveth great lateral agility, just (very politely) tell Him to divine Himself a new draft board. He has more important things to do anyway. As we speak Al Davis is holding a demonic trident and begging to be smited.

The bottom line is that the Chiefs absolutely cannot afford for you to draft an offensive lineman with your first overall pick.

There is perhaps no more important offseason for the Chiefs rebuilding effort than this offseason, because it is so rife with problems. The lack of an agreement between the players and the league likely means that almost all meaningful free agents will be held onto by their current teams. The few players that do make it to the market will have the entire league competing for them. This means that these players will likely be vastly overpaid in accordance to their ability — which is fine if a team is one or two pieces away from a championship run. But if a team is in the budding stage of rebuilding, as we are, every dollar we overpay today is a dollar we can’t pay when we’re looking for the final pieces in a couple years. The less we participate in this offseason’s free agency pool, the better. 

Which makes the Draft all important for this team in 2010. And makes the #5 overall pick for the Chiefs unquestionably the most important aquisition to improve the team this year.

Which is why it has to be a skill position player. This team lacks in a lot of areas, one of the largest of those areas being Cassel’s protection, but you cannot rob a legitimate opportunity to pick up an elite playmaker for the second year in a row. You have no better shot at an elite playmaker than in the Top 10 in the Draft, everywhere else you draft is a much more radical gamble. You can still select an offensive lineman later on in the draft and not gamble nearly as much — they are not impact players, and this is a pretty good year for offensive line depth (it usually always is).

I take Cassel’s protection the most seriously, which is why I believe picking up offensive skill position players would help even more than juicing up the offensive line. We had a pretty decent offensive line in the last quarter of the ’09 campaign, and it wasn’t because the players magically got better, it was because acquiring more skill on your offense has a direct impact on your OL’s quality. Jamaal Charles and Chris Chambers did far more in keeping Cassel upright than O’Callaghan or Wade Smith.

Besides, Brandon Albert needs more time to grow. He was a first round pick, and improved as the year progressed under a new offensive system. Allow him one more year to prove himself. You can get a great LT basically any year if you scout hard enough. All you’re doing in drafting an LT this year is assuring that Albert will move over to RT or guard and improve that position. So we’re essentially spending the #5 overall to upgrade a non-LT position on the offensive line. That is criminal, Scott. Even moreso than using the #3 overall on a three-tech.

We need speed. We need playmakers. We need S Eric Berry, or S Taylor Mays, or RB CJ Spiller, or CB Joe Haden. I’d even reach for WR Dez Bryant or ILB Rolando McClain. I’d rather take a chance grooming QB Jimmy Clausen. Anything to get as much elite talent on the field as possible. That helps this team in the long run. The Browns have the best young left tackle in the NFL and they still had the worst offense in the league in 2009 and Brady Quinn still got the tar kicked out of him.

Offensive lines matter, but the game is built on playmakers.

And #5 overall is where you take them.

Comments
Comments have been disabled for this post.
Sort: Newest | Oldest

[...] That sound you hear is Arrowhead Addict screaming and vomiting.  But Pioli is a value-phile–he drafts for value. And at this point, he sees more value in a key offensive position (LT), than he does in any linebacker or non-Eric Berry safety. Find me if this happens. I have been gathering pitchforks for the better part of a year just in case. [...]

[...] C’mon, Chiefs players. Uche’s upped the ante. We’ve got your platform. Tell us you don’t want Pioli to go left tackle in the first. [...]

[...] for a guy like myself who’s done nothing but rail against going OL with our #5 overall since getting here, this list of mocks is like a stab [...]

[...] as long as the Draft is our only significant means of improving this team this offseason, I don’t wish to take lightly the idea that we absolutely must make the right [...]

[...] As we’ve discussed before, this Draft will not only be the most important step of the Chiefs’ progress this offseason, it will essentially be the only step of the Chiefs’ progress this season. With no deal occuring between the players and the owners, the NFL is undergoing an uncapped year, which will in effect kill free agency: teams will be allowed to hold onto more players, and the few worthwhile players that will make the market will have 32 teams free of cap restrictions bidding on them. The less the Chiefs participate in free agency, the better. [...]

[...] NOTE TO CHIEFS: DON’T GO TACKLE WITH #5 OVERALL from Arrowhead Addict [...]

fuckk yeahhh man aha

Crocker - Taylor Mays at # 5??? The second coming of Roy Williams doesn't excite me too much. Plus, there is a good chance he's still on the board when we draft in the SECOND round.

Okung would be a good pick for the Chiefs at 5. Sure we need some more speed and playmakers but you win in this league in the trenches and we need some help on the offensive line. I don't get all the arguments against drafting an offensive tackle with the 5th pick. I do understand taking Berry over an OT if he's still on the board when we pick.

Go Saints! Become a fan of facebook page here: Colts Will Lose Super Bowl 2010!

I personally hope we get Eric Berry. I think he'll be that good. Pollard could not defend the pass like Berry. Now with that said I would also not be upset if we were to "reach" a little bit at get McClain. But then again I would at least understand if we got Okung. But I have a hard time seeing the logic is drafting just about anybody else (or position). I can friggin GUARANTEE that we don't draft a QB!! LMAO

Culture-changing and elite playmaking ability are the watchwords here. You guys nailed it. Berry and McClain have it (I still think McClain's a reach at #5 overall, but I'll have a topic on that in the upcoming week).

Just don't drain this pick away on the trenches. Albert can man LT for at least one more year, and if he shows drastic improvement on the right side, we won't even have to worry about spending a Top 10 pick on the position...

I must say, I was leaning heavily toward OT until this past week. I think there is a lot to be said for tackles, but I have changed my mind reading the material on McClain and Berry. They both seem like culture changing players, both at positional needs for the Chiefs. If we draft a QB, I will be jumping with Matt. We don't need one, period, with ANY of our picks. I truly think there is going to be a trade down with someone into the lower end of the top 10 or early teens. However, focusing on what we have, from what I am reading McClain is a top 10 talent that would not be a reach. Additionally, he could be the young leader that can be seasoned by Vrabel to be the future of the Chiefs. No OT with the #5? I'm bought in now. Well done.

That's a really nice article actually. It had humor and fact. A mix not always blended so well. I agree completely about the offensive line. They improved. Adn yes it's because of Charles and Chambers as much as anything else. And I don't care. I mean that. TO anyone who wants to argue that point; don't. Because I don't care why. I agree with Andrew's analogy, but that's just me. All I care about is that is IS improved, significantly.

It's a team sport. One part makes the other part better or worse. Everything matters and it's all related somehow. But we need playmakers for sure. We need serious talent here. WE are lacking in that department.

I don't know college well enough to have a serious opinion. I just know we need a center that can START for us, and we need a bad ass NT. A bad ass NT. We need a game changer at that position. We need (Julius Peppers)a defense that can step up. Now is the time to make that happen.

We have to get some superstar talent on that side of the ball immediately. The defense is by far the weakest link, now that Charles has entered the picture so dynamically. A couple of good receivers and we will be on our way offensively. Not set, but moving in the right direction definitely.

We need a NY Jet's defense here. We can work on the rest. But we need a defense. That morale changer when your losing and the defense gets a pic six and now your right back in it type defense.

Yah, defensive royalty. That's what I'm looking for here first. And Crennel knows all about that.

I couldn't agree more with you Andrew! Enough said. lol

It is not just the OL class that is deep, the draft as a whole is deeper than usual thanks to the seemingly impending rookie pay scale. The problem is that while the OL class is deep, it is not as deep as others.

Now instead of going tackle, it's possible that the Chiefs look to go Center, maybe Maurkice Pouncey but that won't happen until 2nd rd. at earliest. In that case they would definitely go skill with 1. (Although still hoping they can trade down)

But then comes the question, who's worth the 5 pick that fit the Chiefs scheme if not going OT?

Berry, Clausen, and maybe McClain.
If Berry maintains his elite designation he makes sense. I don't see him as a Pollard clone.

There is only a slightly better chance of Chiefs picking Clausen than me getting attacked by a shark. If they do, it's only because he is Weis' guy. But if Weis wants one of his guys, more likely to be Golden Tate later.

McClain makes sense but is not being talked about quite as highly as Berry.

We can get a quality tackle at the top of the 2nd round. Looking back to the 07 draft, Joe Thomas was drafted 3rd overall, Joe Staley was picked 28th, Tony Ugoh was picked 42nd, etc. Thomas is clearly a stud (no homo), but Ugoh is no slouch either. I know the Colts are at the top of their game in the scouting and personnel department year after year, but I have faith that Pioli and co. can get a similar find in the 2nd round. Dez Bryant is a wildcard since he missed so much of the year because the NCAA are fascists. McClain is a beast but seems like a reach in the top 5 for a 34 inside backer. I don't see QB happening with 63 milli tied up in Cassel. If Berry is staring us in the face, it's a no-brainer in my opinion. Best player in the draft not named Suh, who isn't a human.

We should be more worried about the bust factor at S, RB, CB, or LB in my opinion.

I respectfully disagree, we could use another great stud top five tackle. Less bust factor in my humble opinion.

I couldn't agree more with the OL, I think if Patriots let Light Go we can get him in free agency. I am really pushing for us to get Eric Berry as the #5. If you look at teams like Colts,Steelers, and Ravens they all have a Pro Bowl Safety even New England when the had Harrison. and they all won SuperBowls. Just look at how bad Steelers were without Troy.

If we take a QB in this draft I will shoot myself. If we take Mays I'll jump off a bridge. If we take a Tackle, it'll be just meh. I would prefer Berry or McClain, like Merlin said, but if they weren't available I'd be ok with a tackle or a trade down.

Berry and McClain are viable picks at #5. So is Okung.

You have a point Andrew.

Jamaal Charles made the offensive line better instantly.

Tony Gonzalez made Tyler Thigpen look like a starting QB.

Pittsburgh had pretty much the exact same defense except for Troy Palamalu. He got injured and they went from winning the Super Bowl to not having any All-Pros.

I highly doubt we'll draft either Mays or Berry with that first pick. Both are Pollard clones and in case you missed it, Pollard just completed a break-out season with the Texans.

I don't see CB as being a very good choice either. We already have two of the best cover corners in the league and their play can only improve once we get the front 7 to where it needs to be.

Using a top 5 pick on a RB is a horrible, ridiculous idea. Shelf life of RBs is very limited compared to other positions and we already have a decent corps of backs with guys like Charles, Battle, Smith, Cox and Castille. I'm not saying we shouldn't look for opportunities to add to this position, I'm just saying we would be crazy to use the #5 pick to do it.

Bryant, Claussen, or McClain, in that order, I can more easily see. As far as QB goes, if Tony Pike were still around at pick #50, I'd like to see us get him. Unfortunately, I don't believe we'll be drafting any QBs in the first 3 rounds because Coach Todd is making the same big mistake that cost Coach Herm his job - believing Brodie Croyle can stay healthy and win games if called upon to do so.