Skip to main content

Matt Prater workout adds another bizarre twist to Chiefs' kicker situation

ByMatt Conner
Buffalo Bills place kicker Matt Prater walks over to the bench during first half action against the Kansas City Chiefs at Highmark Stadium in Orchard Park on Nov. 2, 2025.
Buffalo Bills place kicker Matt Prater walks over to the bench during first half action against the Kansas City Chiefs at Highmark Stadium in Orchard Park on Nov. 2, 2025. | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

They say two wrongs don't make a right. It's also true that two confounding things fail to bring any clarity.

From the outside looking in to Arrowhead Stadium, it's impossible to figure out exactly what the Kansas City Chiefs are thinking when it comes to addressing their placekicker concerns. Both their ongoing support of a clearly struggling Harrison Butker and their odd approach to competition has only brought more questions and drama around a decision that seems very straightforward. On Tuesday, the Chiefs only added to the intrigue.

Veteran kicker Matt Prater was one of a handful of players who worked out for the Chiefs ahead of Week 11. That the Chiefs are trying out various players is par for the course. It behooves a front office to stay updated on potential names to call in case injuries happen or emergencies arise. But Prater's name among the lot, and the invitation issued to yet another kicker, just feels weird.

Chiefs already have two kickers and plenty of questions

The Chiefs currently employ Harrison Butker as the kicker on the active roster. The Chiefs also have veteran Justin Tucker on the practice squad. The former has missed all but two of eight field goals from 50 yards or more, putting his job in obvious jeopardy, despite his clutch performances that helped establish a dynasty. The latter is a recently suspended veteran accused of sexual misconduct who was inconsistent back in 2024, when he last kicked in the NFL.

If that sounds like a rather unflattering picture—well, it is. That's why the Chiefs are paying as much attention to kicker as they are, and yet, they're also doing nothing. It's confounding.

At this point, the ineffectiveness from Butker has brought plenty of fan derision and questions of Andy Reid at press conferences. But in such moments, Reid has gone all-in on a supportive approach for Butker. Even wtih another kicker taking up a practice squad spot, which brings up questions about the allocations of roster spots on its own, the Chiefs have stayed committed to Butker through thin and... thin. Even with Tucker at the ready, Butker's consistent misses haven't moved the meter.

Matt Prater workout comes at a strange time for Harrison Butker

In Week 10's win over the Atlanta Falcons, Butker went a perfect 5-for-5 kicking extra points and nailed an unofficial 41-yard field goal, which was his only attempt during the game. But now, after Butker finally has a steady performance, the Chiefs are flirting with another kicker with two already on the roster.

None of this really has anything to do with Prater. The 42-year-old kicker has been around the block a time or two, mostly with the Detroit Lions and Denver Broncos. He converted 18 of 20 field goals a year ago with the Buffalo Bills but he's been a free agent for the first half of the '26 campaign thus far. On paper, he'd be a fine option for the Chiefs if they were ready to move on from Butker.

What exactly is the Chiefs' plan at kicker?

But therein lies the (further) confusion. Are the Chiefs ready for a change from Harrison Butker at long last? If so, why wait until after his steadiest day in several weeks? And if there's a change afoot, why would the team not just elevate the one they already have on the practice squad? And if there's an issue with both Butker (effectivenss) and Tucker (public relations), then why even bring in Tucker in the first place knowing the optics ahead of time?

It's always a good idea to keep a pulse on the free-agent market. Knowing which kicker to call in case a need arises is being responsible. But checking in on another kicker after already signing a kicker yet failing to make a move at kicker when kicker is a glaring issue... well, it's all a muddled mess.

Add us as a preferred source on Google