Josh Downs scouting report explains the appeal and concerns behind Chiefs trade

Coming into the 2026 trade deadline, the Chiefs' front office made it very clear that their top priority was to land Patrick Mahomes a new pass-catching weapon. Today, Brett Veach and his staff landed on their target and took advantage of the Indianapolis Colts' fire sale. Just before the deadline, Kansas City finalized a trade, sending fourth- and fifth-round picks to the Colts for Josh Downs and a seventh-round pick.

Downs is a skilled receiver who comes with elite speed and burst, making him a versatile inside-out threat for the Kansas City offense. While he is on an expiring contract, the Chiefs maneuvered for value, knowing that if Downs (or Rashee Rice) hits free agency, they will likely get a fourth- or fifth-round pick. So, essentially, the final value of this trade will be Josh Downs in exchange for moving down two or three rounds in the draft.

Josh Downs' college scouting profile reveals his potential

This is great value for a receiver of Downs' caliber. Coming out of college, I scouted Downs and placed a second-round grade on him. In college, Downs was a favorite target for two future NFL quarterbacks, Sam Howell and Drake Maye. He went for over 1,000 yards in back-to-back seasons in 2021 and 2022 and was selected by the Colts with the 79th pick in the draft. That was later than I expected, and early in his career, he proved to be a steal.

In his time in college, Downs transformed from a deep threat/gadget guy to more of a traditional WR. He often made an impact as a punt returner, and North Carolina diligently worked to get him the ball in space. He also impressed downfield and consistently was able to stretch the field for the Tar Heels' quarterbacks, who quickly worked their way to the NFL.

In his pre-draft report, I noted Downs' 4.48-second 40-yard dash time was underwhelming, but his play speed was always quicker than that. In his combine testing, Downs proved his explosiveness when he logged a 38.5-inch vertical jump and a 131-inch broad jump. These numbers would place Downs in the 82nd and 92nd percentiles in each of those tests, proving that his athleticism and explosiveness would translate to the NFL level.

I largely projected Downs would fit best in the NFL as a WR3 or a true slot receiver because of his route-running and athleticism. He fits the mold of what the Chiefs often look for from a wide receiver, and Andy Reid will be excited about Downs' ability to separate on the outside. His skills have already translated to the league, and Kansas City will be excited to have an established weapon for Mahomes to work with this season.

What Josh Downs brings to the Chiefs offense

Since reaching the NFL, Downs has played 3.5 years and has totaled 56 games. He averages a little over four catches and 44 yards per game and has consistently proven to be a valuable receiving threat for the Colts' offense. His separation downfield has been routinely noticed by scouts, and Downs comes to Kansas City with the most yards among receivers on the roster.

The Colts' wide receiver situation this year has stretched Josh Downs’ skill set and has allowed him to prove his versatility. Downs has primarily lined up in the slot, where his quickness and early separation have helped him make an impact on offense. Downs also plays faster than his 40 time would suggest, and in college, Downs made a lot of downfield impact as well. The Chiefs will likely use Downs mainly out of the slot, but Andy Reid is known for getting creative with receivers like Him and will likely get him involved in a variety of ways this season. 

The downside with Downs that many fans and analysts will note is that his play style is a lot more of the same. His speed and athleticism are notable, but many Chiefs fans would argue that we have a slew of undersized receivers with speed and raw athletic ability. There will be questions about how much his impact will be felt in the Kansas City offense.

On the other hand, Down's positives are simple. He fits the offense and is the type of player Andy Reid and Brett Veach have loved to add at receiver for years. He is an established pass-catcher with NFL experience who immediately makes an impact on the offense. He is on an expiring contract and is eligible for free agency this offseason, which means extension talks could enter the picture if he flashes late in the season for the Chiefs.

Overall, the Downs trade is one fans should be excited about, as it was a low-cost move and the Chiefs got the type of weapon they love to work with. The results may take some time, and we will see how the trade pans out. But Downs immediately brings a spark to the Kansas City offense and hopefully can rekindle some confidence in Patrick Mahomes and his pass catchers.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow