This Should Be The End Of The Matt Cassel Era In KC

by Chiefs

Let me be very clear, I really like Matt Cassel. I’ve liked him since he set foot in Kansas City. He seems like a great guy and a great teammate. He’s a hard worker and it’s hard not to cheer for the guy. He’s the ultimate underdog having never played a single game at QB in college. I even drove the Matt Cassel bandwagon for a while. So this is not a piece penned by a “Cassel Hater.”

The numbers speak for themselves. Matt Cassel hasn’t been good enough for the KC Chiefs. Here are here his final numbers as KC’s starting QB:

57.2% Completion Percentage
6.4 Yards Per Attempt
198.8 Yards Per Game
53 TDs to 32 INTs
18 Wins to 21 Losses

For me the two biggest numbers I look at are completion percentage and YPA. To me, that shows if a QB is accurate, and if he can get the ball down the field. Matt Cassel’s numbers in those departments just aren’t good enough. For comparison, here are the career numbers in those categories for some “less than great” NFL QBs:

Matt Moore: 59.4% and 6.8 YPA
Tarvaris Jackson: 59.3% and 6.7 YPA
Rex Grossman: 54.7% and 6.5 YPA

Let’s just say Cassel’s numbers don’t put him in good company, and worse, he is not improving.

Here are the stats from Cassel’s first nine games in a Chiefs uniform:

55.0%, 6.0 YPA, 191.1 YPG, 12 TDs, 6 INTs

Here are the stats from Cassel’s last 9 games (and hopefully his last) as a Chief:

59.5%, 6.4 YPA, 190.3 YPG, 10 TDs, 9 INTs

Before anyone says his numbers this year are down because of his protection, keep in mind that in those first nine games he was sacked 34 times compared to the 22 times so far this season. Cassel simply has not progressed, despite the fact that his WRs are MUCH improved. They’ve gone from an inconsistent Bowe paired with Bobby Wade and Terrence Copper to a Pro Bowl Bowe with Breaston and Baldwin, and Cassel just isn’t any better.

It’s time to move on.

Never miss a chance to get your fix! Follow Arrowhead Addict on Twitter and be sure to like our Facebook page.

Comments
Comments have been disabled for this post.
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Man, you guys are all over the place today. Unfortunately when your team is losing then that is what happens. The truth is everybody partially right and partially wrong. The ugly truth is Cassel is not nor will he ever be an elite QB in this league. He is a good serviceable back up but that is all. In his defense the offensive line did him no favors or rather Richardson did him no favors. That is part of the problem. He does not help himself by calling out the appropriate protection schemes. There is much more to being an elite QB than having a great arm. Forget about getting Manning. Irsay is not that kind of guy. Knowing Peyton was hurt he still gave him a contract that made him the highest paid QB in the league. He did not place him on IR, thus allowing Manning to get fully paid. He won't turn his back on him now.

Ok. To all you Cassel Haters wat free agent Qb is better than Cassel? Wat rookie can u draft(not named A.Luck cus we wont hav that high a pk) that wud lead us to a SuperBowl? I been saying this over an over again the Oline is too horible to field any QB that u not planing on getn killed!!!

@MicahStephenson Dude the O-line isn't the problem Cassel has happy feet and rather run then make his reads.. Look at the history if Cassel get's blitzed within the first Quarter of the game then he starts to get scared opposed to Brady or Rogers who manages to stay in the pocket or move around.. Look at what Palko did in the last few seconds of the game he managed to avoid getting sack by moving in the opposited direction of the pressure and at least get a field goal out of it. It looks like the O-line but it's not. Cassel is hanging on to the ball way longer and making his reads way longer he's also slow at making his reads and therefore he gets happy feet and starts running for his life again.. How long do you expect the line to hold with a QB who has a slow release and a slow read??? We don't need to go into free agency for a QB we already have a QB until the end of the year just need to give him snaps and time.. Cassel was the problem I've been saying that for the last two years...

@MicahStephenson I'll take Matt Barkley or Landry Jones in the 1st round in a HEART BEAT. Their TALENT is simply higher, so their ceiling is higher. that's the problem with cassel, he has maximized his talent. if you are ok with a "mediocre" qb, that's fine. However, I believe you need an ELITE QB to win a SB in today's game.

@jpopejoy@MicahStephenson Agreed. A team without an elite QB is not going to win the Super Bowl. There was Trent Dilfer with the Ravens, who had the best defense in the NFL. Then there was........Well, you get the point. Cassel is, always was and always will be a middle of the road QB. We have the talent to get where we need to be if we had the right guy to lead us there. Pioli, the clock is ticking. Not on the talent, but with the fans. You and Hunt are slowly killing the Golden Geese. The Chiefs Nation.

I can't argue much but I will point something out. He plays behind one of the worst pass protecting lines in the world. Tom Brady might not have much better numbers with no protection. This could be a situation where nobody appreciated what he does until he's gone.

@big chief said it earlier and i'll say it again...going into the Miami game, the Kansas City Chiefs had given up the fewest sacks in the NFL. also, did you see Brady Sunday night? Jets were all over him, but he got the ball out of his hands quickly. Did you see Rodgers Monday night? He moves all around the pocket and gives himself more time, or he gets rid of the ball quicker. Cassel has a SLOW release, and his reads are slow as well. sometimes a line helps a QB, sometimes a QB helps a line...i feel like Cassel doesn't help our line when they have bad games.

@jpopejoy @big chief fewest sacks? But how many in the last 2 games? How many sacks did cassel avoid by runing his for his life soon as the ball is snapedo? Get the ball out his hands quiker to who? The wrs arnt getn open. Move around in wat pocket? Brady and Rogers wud FAIL behind wat is now b n called the worst oline n the NFL.

Personally, I'm hoping this is the end of Cassel as a starting QB. You never know... a lot of good QB's were discovered through an injured starter. This could Palko's time to shine. Yeah... it's unlikely, but you never know. Probably more like impossible with our remaining schedule. I'd say if he even does "pretty well" with our remaining schedule, he should remain our starter over Cassel..... because we all know Cassel would suck over our remaining schedule against mostly +.500 teams. I'm all for drafting a QB in the first round next season and starting him day 1... that way we don't waste any time getting him experience while our other players age.

@IBleedRed2011 I have this hunch that at the end of the season Palko's numbers will look a lot like Cassel's.

Here's my take on trying to acquire Manning, or another REAL QB. Roll back the clock to Dick Vermiel. We have an offense that to me is every bit as capable as those of Dick Vermiel's. I realize that we don't have the O line, or anywhere near it. But we did lead the league in rushing last year, so if we can get that line where it needs to be, this would be a dangerous offense. If you look at the receivers, running backs, and a healthy Charles and Moeaki, we have more weapons than those 2000+ teams. I really think that we are one draft and a few good FA's away to make a big run to in the playoffs. The mistake would be to try and groom a rookie, and let the talent we have either grow old or lose some of them in free agency.

@RICK TORREY I don't hate that idea. It would just depend on the price for Manning. You can't sell off your entire future in draft picks if their is the slightest chance the guy's health isn't ever going to be right again. If he checked out medically and we could get a few runs at the SB before he calls it a career I'd be all for it. We could still groom Stanzi or another draft pick for the future.

Ideas must work through the brains and the arms of good and brave, or they are no better than dreams.Thanks for the post.

I believe that if we sell the farm to get one of the top three QB's in this coming draft, we will be setting him up for failure. I seriously doubt if even Peyton if healthy could win consistently with this Chief's team. They really aren't nearly as good as most of you think they are. You talk of several pro bowl players, well lets see how many pro bowl players you will be talking about after the next 5 games. I would suggest that we draft players to fix the offensive and defensive lines and perhaps draft an interim QB until we are able to sell the farm for a franchise one. Weeden from OK St is 28 yrs old and could probably play at a high level to get us into the playoffs until we are ready to go for the super bowl. He is a QB with size and a great arm, and with a calm demeanor that would give him a chance to start right out of the gate. Just what we need at this time. If we sell the farm right now I think it would be a disaster. by the way Big Jim, I am soon 78 in a couple of weeks and my clock is running down too.

@jimfromkc it's very clear it all starts w/ QB. Chiefs are 4-5 without peyton, Colts are 0-9, so to say he couldn't win w/ our talent is absolutely insane. It's a QB league and we need one. We have playmakers at WR and RB, but not one to get them the ball. Also, we won't need to "sell the farm" to get Jones or Barkley...we'll probably not need to move ANYWHERE to get barkley. only one you'll have to give up everything for is Luck, and i'm 100% ok w/ that

@jpopejoy @jimfromkc how can u compare cassel to Manning mayby the best QB of all time. Thats like a team saying our RB sucks cus hes is not as good as Jim Brown was or our wr sucks cus hes not as good as Jerry Rice was!

@jimfromkc You are absolutely right about getting the lines fixed. That is imperative to any QB's success. Luck is the only player in the draft that I would "sell the farm for". Any of the others will probably fall to us with our pick in the first round. Luck is the exception and if you have a chance you have to take him. Just because Cassel got knocked around it was not always the lines fault. He has to recognize defenses and call the protection schemes. I think he misses the reads all too often. If we can't get Luck (and I think that is likely) then there are several outstanding QB's out there. I personally like Griffin III from Baylor. Incrediblly accurate and very athletic. Right now after Luck, he is one of the front runners for the Heisman. I think he may very well fall to us. Then I think you go after offensive tackle and defensive line. What we do not draft then hopefully can pick up in free agency. I am at a loss as to why Haley is not playing Gaither. He has to be better than Richardson. I don't believe the Colts would trade Peyton right after they just gave him this huge contract. They have more loyalty than that. I can see you understand our frustration with our age.

@Big Jim@jimfromkc RG3 won't even be a 1st round pick. he's not rated in the top 32 by scouts inc. That's not a type of QB i want anyway...the "run first" qbs rarely win you much in the NFL imo

@jpopejoy@jimfromkc I would agree with you if he was a run first QB. He is primarily a pocket passer with the ability to run, but rarely does so. He is 6'2" and 220. This season he has completed 224 of 302 pass attempts for 3093 total yards with 74.2% completion rate. Also has 29 TD's with only 5 INT. I like those numbers and they are real.

@Big Jim@jimfromkc good point, but be wary, he is one of those "spread offense" college guys that rack up a ton of stats in the pro's, but don't pan out in college (jason white, pat white, etc)

@Big Jim@jimfromkc Yeah, Griffin makes me nervous. He just seems like a high bust factor player to me, but I'll be honest I haven't watched him all that much. As far as Gaither goes, this seems like the perfect time to make that switch. With Palko being left handed the RT is now protecting the QBs blind side. Gaither has experience doing that as the Ravens LT. I think the Chiefs have to at least try it so that Palko has a fighting chance out there.

I think Cassel would be an excellent back up quarterback in anyones book.

I don't know what the Front Office will do if at season end we get a shot at a top prospect at QB. First, they have Stanzi (who IMO should start ahead of Palko, I think he can manage to play under fire - and that'd be a great test before the draft) then Pioli likes his QB Cheap : Brady was a bargain, and Stanzi can be one (or another guy next draft), but despite all the talent Brady has, he could play behind Bledsoe who despite no being and HOFer, was to me a better overall QB than Cassel. Cassel can be a fine teacher, but I don't feel he's enough to be the Vet to propel a top rookie out of college to NFL's hieghts. Then, can Pioli be deaf to trades sirens or to draft a RT or defense. All in all I agree Cassel will not be the guy some thought he could become, because simply he's not the QB to support the weight of an offense if he has to. some homework has to be done, but looking at Ponder or Newton, I feel we should take a chance at one of the better QB prospect if we're in position to do so. Another VET should eb brought in, and another QB Coach. BEcause I feel if KC ends low in the ranking, Haley will be canned, and Zorn can be promoted as OC. I'dlike to see Trent Green, or Gannon or Kurt Warner as QB coach. Other point : next season, demoting Cassel, or firing him would mean that Pioli/Haley admit errors. Can/would they ?

@Olivier_French_Chief lot's of info there, lol. I don't think this would be an admission of error on Haley...I think he's handcuffed to Cassel, and unfairly so. However, I have no idea if Pioli would admit it. The funny thing is...he wants things the "patriot" way, but if Bellicheck makes a mistake w/ a player he just cuts them or trades them. I'm curious why people think Stanzi will be good? I'm a big 10 guy (IU) and watched quite a bit of of that Iowa team. He could only MANAGE a game in college, that isn't enough. He's actually a less talented Tebow (how scary is that?). They drafted him b/c he's a leader and they were hoping, but there is no way this guy will be an NFL starting QB. As far as Brady...i knew one of the scouts on that NE team then...they *all* thought brady was playing some serious football in training camp/preseason, and a lot of them were excited for Brady to get a chance to play...so it's not like he just came in and was a total shock to the staff, they'd seen a lot of promise that year from him. We just gotta take Jones or Barkley...or my preference, offer "the house" for the #1 overall and get Luck. If they turn out to be a bust, hey, i'll live with that. It's like in baseball...bases loaded, bottom of the 9th, 2 outs...you gotta take the bat off your shoulder and swing. if we miss, i can accept that, but I'm sick of accepting not even taking a swing since i was TWO YEARS OLD (todd blackledge)

@jpopejoy Can't tell me about Stanzi. Here in France I don't follow much NCAA football, and I just buy crossing scout reports at draft time. And I clearly agree : if in position to do so next draft IS the time to take a shot at a hot college prospect.

@jpopejoy@Olivier_French_Chief I want to finally thank Haley for benching Cassell like I've been saying for the last two years is Cassell sucks and he's not a dependable QB he's more of backup and not a starter.. Palko was in for at least 3 plays and at least got us in field goal range with the time that he was given..

@Olivier_French_Chief Olivier, you say Pioli likes his QBs cheap? He was the guy who signed Cassel for 63 MIL. And right now, that experiment should end, and the Stanzi era, hopefully , should begin. I don't see Palko as any more than a fill-in, and the Chiefs need to see if Stanzi can be an NFL QB. If he doesn't get some starts soon, then next year we go back to the drawing board and draft another guy, and the merry-go-round continues. This is just another example of Haley and Pioli not being ready for another injury to the most important player on the offense. As far as I know, Stanzi hasn't even dressed. At this point we know that neither of the QBs are going to win any games with the schedule, but we can at least see if they can play. If Stanzi shows a good deal of promise, then we don't waste a pick on another one. But with Palko, we have just another wasted year of broken promises by our Chiefs.

@RICK TORREY I meant Cheap because I can't recall Pioli drafting a QB real high in the draft

I agree and the numbers have said it all. If he just didn't stare down his recievers and get them killed maybe they would catch the ball. Granted the offensive line woes are a lot of the problem. Along with a change of offensive coordinators every year he has been in KC and a control freak like Haley. Odds were not in Cassels favor. I think if Palko does well it may seal his fate. If the numbers are the same of better from Palko, I think the Chiefs have no choice but to look else where. I have always felt weary of the trade with the Patriots and of Matt "The Donkey" Cassel. He is just a more durable Broky Cryole. I hope Palko does well. What are the repercussions of realizing everything you invested in Cassel? Will Haley remain as coach, after all I really think he has made a mess of everything with his coaching staff. Firing Chan and losing Wies, coaching it himself, and now Muir. The beginning of the season and getting the players ready to play, how did the that work out Berry, Moeaki, Charles all out with leg issues. How can anyone forget the embarassing losses at the beginning of the season. Does Haley Survive until the end of the year? The Chiefs are very talented, is that talent being used correctly?

For you that want to look at the draft for a QB who is going to mentor a guy fresh out college? Do we look for a veteran QB to do that? Who? Do we get a veteran to play a year? What do the Chiefs do with their QB situation? Keep Cassel and draft a QB? That wouldn't work, get a veteran and develop Stanzi? Even if could figure that out o-line need to be re-tooled.

1st QB should be starting by week 5, esp if we end up w/ one of those 3 (luck, jones, barkley). you take your lumps, while the entire team is young. These are things that teams in the NFL do every year. They are reasonable questions, but they are also not difficult ones. a couple NFL teams have to answer these every year. @AK.

@AK. come on man...every Doctor in this world will tell you there is NOTHING YOU CAN DO to prevent ACL tears. They are unpredictable and not related to physical shape. Also, after having a private conversation w/ a chiefs scout close to the organization, Weis leaving was about his kid's health and his own health. Haley took the "talent" that Herm Edwards had...Turned bowe from an inconsistent crybaby into a Probowl and a leader. Tamba Hali from a borderline 1st round bust into a Probowler. Derrick Johnson from a borderline 1st round bust into a a solid LB who has been getting some Probowl talk this year. Oh ya...Charles from the bench to one of the best RBs in the game. Looks like he's also well on his was to turning and immature diva in Baldwin into the "right type of player". 2 wins to 10 in 2 years? i think he probably has maximized talent in a lot of areas. I'm not a haley apologist, but i do think people are over looking A LOT and putting all the weight in how he handled the preseason, which was obviously a mistake. However, moving forward, I do agree he needs to let go of the offense more and leave it to the coordinator...but that's also the growing pains of a young nfl coach.

Oh, I wish it weren't so. But alas, it is so. Those number comparisons are pretty striking.

Well said Lyle. Nice job. I have been a Cassel fan too. However, 6 weeks ago when I wrote a piece saying it's... Time To Go... for Cassel I began to look at his numbers too and that's what really turned me around. The Chiefs promptly went on a 4 game winning streak and the push to get rid of Cassel subsided. The numbers I found were simply his game by game passer rating numbers. They show no progress. He's up and down and all over the place. But, no progress. If Palko does well at all... that should seal Matt's fate.

Your 100% right on my feelings exactly. He seems like a good guy but he can't get this team to the next level. But I also think theirs no way pioli will admit his mistake (yet) and give him at least one more year. Think Matt Barkley will fall to us at #6???

@Socalchiefs barkely is projected around 18 right now....but more importantly, some of those teams that will finish worse than us don't need a QB (Rams, Panthers, Vikings). We'll definitely have a chance to take Barkley or even possibly Landry Jones

@jpopejoy@Socalchiefs The Rams are not in the market for a QB. $72 bazzilion on Bradford. Just because he has had the sophmore slump ( a REALLY BAD sophmore slump) does not mean the rams will be looking to replace Bradford with a first round pick. And Carolina? Ever heard of a dude named Cam Newton that might be making a run at rookie of the year? Carolina will be looking to boost the O line to give the new kid some protection.

@ColoradoChief @jpopejoy@Socalchiefs He didn't say they needed QB's. Re-read his comment. "but more importantly, some of those teams that will finish worse than us don't need a QB (Rams, Panthers, Vikings)."

@ColoradoChief @Socalchiefs reread that one more time buddy. i said they WON'T need a QB...those damn contractions are hard to understand ;)

@Socalchiefs What is your take on Barkley compared to those in years past, I know he's better than Jon David Bootey, but is he better than Mark Sanchez? Is he Carson Palmer material?

Right on target Lyle, and I know it gives you no personal pleasure to site the numbers. You know I have been preaching that Cassel is not the man for quite some time. I agree that he is the nicest kid you would ever want to meet and nobody outworks him. He gives everything he has but it just is not enough. He had one very good year when Brady went down, but that was with a legitimate Super Bowl caliber team and a guy named Randy Moss making him look better than he was. What bothers me is that I believe that Pioli had to know that, and STILL brought him here. What is even worse is that we ALL drank the Pioli koolaide because we wanted to believe that we finally had the elite QB we all wanted and he was not at the end of his career. Then we kept accepting the excuses as to why we were not seeing what was clearly being shown to us. We bought it because of the abberation of last year and our inability to beat the quality teams. Now we get to start over AGAIN. I can't speak for everyone, but I am 63 and tired of starting over. This franchise has been supported like no other in the NFL. Win or lose we filled that stadium. No other franchise in the entire league has given that kind of support, so Mr Pioli please don't make us wait any more. We DESERVE BETTER.

I also think Pioli could convince himself that in a weak division, with Charles, Berry and Moeaki coming back (hopefully able to play), Cassel is good enough to make a run at the division title. He might be right.

@KC Oracle Only a complete idiot would think Cassel is a Super Bowl quarterback though Oracle, and Pioli is not. He is arrogant though and would leave Cassel in because he picked him. Kinda like cutting off your nose to spite your face. Can he win a division title sure he can with talent like that around him, but thats it no further. He just doesnt have the accuracy or the ice in his viens. Trent Dilfers happen from time to time but our defense is not as stout as his was.

@kc Wow you commented on yourself and I didn't read it sorry about that bro.

I agree that it is highly unlikely that Cassel is good enough to take the Chiefs deep in the playoffs and probably needs to be replaced. But he will probably be back next year because Pioli is unlikely ot admit a mistake (Cassel did have a good year last year and has some leadership qualities) and he is relatively cheap at $5.25 Million. Most likely, he will be starter with a young QB learning as a back up.

@KC Oracle Here's the thing, Pioli wants to win a Super Bowl. Another year of Cassel is another year of putting off finding a QB that can get us there. Let's hope that his desire to get his own ring without Darth Hoodie so he can brag about how great he is on his own is greater then his fear to admit he was wrong.

@LyleGraversen @kc despite recent success of others, I don't think it is a good idea to drop our starter, draft a rookie, and hope for the best. I think oracle has the right idea, draft a rookie, let him learn the playbook, without getting nailed on the right side by whoever brich is blocking, while Cassel takes the punishment. Then the next year use 1st round pick to draft a world beater at tackle. Then the sophmore QB will have a chance to thrive.

@Gjrchief@LyleGraversen@kc Sounds like a good plan. Of course, it is dependent upon findnig the right young QB. Right now, that looks like the next QB is the decision that will make or break Pioli in KC. It also lets Pioli chase a division title one more time with Cassel; gives Pioli one last chance at $5.25 Million cheap price to see if Cassel can reward Pioli's judgment three years ago.

@Gjrchief@kc If BRich is starting again next week it will be a failure by the Chiefs, if he's starting again next season then a whole mess of people deserve to be fired.