Merlin's Magic: Chief Secrecy Edition

by Features

I had a whole different post prepared for this week, but the Chief’s penchant for secrecy keeps irritating me. It took today for my thoughts to galvanize on the subject. Bloggers tend to be among the most hard-core of fans. Regardless of if I agree with your opinions or if you show up to Arrowhead with a toilet seat around your neck, I respect the fan that sticks with their team, win or lose. In my opinion, bloggers are a canary in the coal mine for football fans. Since Clark Hunt went off into his undisclosed location and conducted a stealth set of interviews for a new GM, the blogger tone started to shift, and not in a good way.

The NFL has become successful due to rabid hard core fans buying tickets and merchandise. Also, the casual fan has to be engaged. This combination has helped to make the NFL highly successful. Surely you don’t think all these uniform changes and retro uniform days are about anything else but marketing additional stuff to fans? The NFL has many of us hooked and needs to keep us hooked as our economy continues to struggle.

However, this secrecy may have the effect of driving away fans. Hardcore fans tend to think of their team in terms of ‘we’ and ‘us’. This is a great thing for the NFL. Fans that feel a part of the team are less likely to turn away and more likely to dedicate their own scarcer resources to feeding the bloated NFL beast. Now, when the Chiefs start guarding basic information like coaches’ roles and act like every scrap of information is on the level of war secrets, they chip away at that fan loyalty. Here is the bottom line. When you are this secretive, you are acting as if you believe your fans are the enemy. When you treat fans that way, they are less likely to think of the team as ‘we’ or ‘us’. Instead, you become a ‘them’. A ‘them’ is much easier to dismiss than an ‘us’. For example, my wife and I talk about the Chiefs fairly often. I have noticed myself referring to the Chiefs much more as ‘the Chiefs’ or ‘they’ or ‘them’. The words ‘we’ and ‘us’ are becoming less common.

So, this is a message to Kremlin Scott, Clark Hunt and anyone else who thinks they are running the invasion of Europe in WW2. You are losing fan identity with the way you are conducting your business. You are abusing a precious gift. Once that gift is lost, it is very hard to get back. Mess with player access during training camp, especially family fun night and I will be one pissed off blogger. Guys, you are leading a team with a rabid, loyal fan base that is dying to support you. Treat us like we are part of the family. We are your life bread. Respect us, do not dismiss us. For what we give, I don’t think that is asking too much.

Never miss a chance to get your fix! Follow Arrowhead Addict on Twitter and be sure to like our Facebook page.

Comments
Comments have been disabled for this post.
Sort: Newest | Oldest

I disagree with this entire post. First of all, it's February, and the fact that the Chiefs have an air-tight front office doesn't make me less of a fan. I really don't need to be inside the coaches office to be considered "more" of a fan than a blogger. I also disagree that bloggers are more hardcore fans. I appreciate the information certain bloggers find, but that doesn't mean that a blogger is "more of a fan" ... And finally, do you really think Scott Pioli is keeping information from fans because fans are "enemies"? I think you are confusing fans with media and the competition of the rest of the NFL. But, since you blogged this, I guess you're more of a fan than me, so perhaps I'm wrong ...

well the secrecy wont hurt a thing I dont think I wish they would tell just me though

Thank you Chiefs447

I find the secrecy to be entertaining we all get to sit and think what we would do if we were in Piolis shoes and he gets to make an informed decision. And what good would it have done them to be more open. Were they going to have a press release every other day saying what they may or may not do?? I for one dont mind how we get there as long as we get there. Now all we need to do is get Peppers and Haynesworth :)

Ditto to what Jeremy said... again.

All 32 teams are competing with each other.

It is a copy cat league.

Pioli's reputation as a personnel man is exceptional. People want to copy him and know what he is doing.

I would keep things secret too if I thought all eyes were wathcing me, watching who I was watching (draft/FA), and trying to ride my coat tails.

Go ahead Mr. Pioli, do your bsuiness in private. Your in competition with 31 other teams, don't tip your hat.

I am surpised about some of the attitudes here. Carl Petersen wasn't to open either.

Am I starved for news, hell yes, I am a KC addict, but in the immortal (horrible) words of Herm "this is a good thing, its not a bad thing".

Well stated, Merlin.

An addendum to that is that working on developing goodwill with the fans and making them feel a part of the team will also mean that you're going to get a lot more slack from those fans whenever your team struggles then you will if you portray yourself as the arrogant, paranoid asshole who thinks the fans should somehow be grateful when he hires failed retreads like Clancy Pendergast and Gary Gibbs.

And if this team struggles this season (which they may very well do considering all the changes) the biggest thing that Pioli's secrecy game is going to do is make him look really ridiculous. I think Pioli's got the ability to be a great GM, but he hasn't had close to the level of success to merit being treated like a great GM. Right now, he's very much a question mark...just like everyone else running this team, and he needs to keep that in mind in how the Chiefs interact with the fans.

I am ok with the secrecy!!

It's like football porn once a week!!!!!

The Broncos picked up Weigmann as an unrestricted free agent. I'm guessing that the Chiefs lost more FA's than they gained last year and considering how well Weigmann performed I would expect that they'll get pretty decent draft compensation as a result. Maybe somebody can confirm on the FA +/- ?

"I respectfully disagree.

There is no reason to air out the KC business even to the fans. The Staff only owe one thing to the fans: a winning team.

This secrecy does not alienate me."

+1

hey question you guys. Maybe someone touched on this so sorry if we have and thanks for catching me up, but I was thinking about Casey Wiegmann and how that guy made the freaking pro-bowl this year. Was he cut or did he leave via free agency? If he left during free agency won't we get some sort of draft pick compensation in round 4-7? should be a higher pick too since he went to the pro-bowl right?

Maybe we already have a deal done with Peppers, ie going to a 3-4?

Ditto to what Jeremy said.

Merlin I agree with your statement "the casual fan has to be engaged". Some KC fans simply want to sit down and read a post that doesnt require them to "think too much" after a hard day at work. Adam I see that in some of your posts such as "your favorite tailgating food" etc and personally think there is a real need for those.

Adam:

Perhaps, I for one have never interviewed or been offered a job without knowing what that job is.

Totally understand, Merl. Here's the thing, though. I'm not sure the Chiefs have totally figured out what all of these coaches' roles will be, they just know that they want them here. I'm also not at all convinced that they have their defensive coordinator yet.

Thanks Jeremy...YOU SURE YOU DON'T HAVE ANYTHING ELSE TO SAY?

Chiefs Defense-TM-Chiefs Feb. 18 - 12:57 pm et

Despite the additions of Gary Gibbs and Clancy Pendergast to their coaching staff, ESPN's John Clayton suggests that the Chiefs could still hire Romeo Crennel to coordinate their defense.

Crennel known GM Scott Pioli well and would bring a strict 3-4 defense to Kansas City. It's uncertain if the 61-year-old wants the job, however.
Source: ESPN Insider

I understand what you're saying, Merlin, and I don't entirely disagree. I am a huge fan and love to follow all aspects of the team--and they are making it tough becasue there is literally nothing to follow.

Fans do care about this stuff--today. But by the time the draft comes around and this has all been announced, everyone, including me, will have forgotten. As long as the product on the field improves, they can be Fort Knox for all I care.

I've been having the same thoughts Merlin. This level of uberstealth can be a real buzz kill. For Chiefs fans, it's always been more than just simply winning. It's been just as much about identifying, relating, participating, anticipating, and the overall sense of inclusion.

Adam Schefter
What will move to 3-4 mean to Chiefs’ Dorsey?
Posted: Adam Schefter | Adam Schefter | Tags: Glenn Dorsey, Kansas City Chiefs

Kansas City announced its coaching staff this week. What it didn’t announce is that the Chiefs are planning to switch to a 3-4 defense.

Under the guidance of new defensive coaches Clancy Pendergast and Gary Gibbs, the Chiefs are turning to the defense that has done so well for Pittsburgh and is back in vogue in the NFL. The Chiefs are going 3-4.

Now Kansas City is going to have to tailor its personnel accordingly. But what is most intriguing and mysterious about it is where last year’s first-round pick, defensive tackle Glenn Dorsey, fits in. Dorsey might not be stout enough to play nose tackle in a 3-4, and he might not be big enough to play end in that style of defense.

One year after becoming Kansas City’s top pick, there now are questions about Dorsey’s role.

But the changes now are coming fast and furious in Kansas City, mainly on defense.

Posted in: Adam Schefter | ShareThis

Can you say Romeo Crennel healing from hip surgery?

I respectfully disagree.

There is no reason to air out the KC business even to the fans. The Staff only owe one thing to the fans: a winning team.

This secrecy does not alienate me.