Father Knows Best?: Super Bowl Edition

In this series, Dr. John Best, aka the Sports Doc, will take on his son, “Arrowhead” Adam Best. They will debate the Chiefs, the NFL and various other topics in order to discover if father really does know best.

The Old Chief: Adam,

Everyone is missing the obvious on this Super Bowl. While everyone is focusing on Larry Fitzgerald, I feel the most important player on the field is Casey Hampton. Yes, Casey is at bat again. The eight-year veteran from Texas is responsible for up the middle push as well as stopping the run. Why is this important? Kurt Warner steps up in the pocket, often avoiding the rush from linebackers and defensive ends. With a strong push up front, it will decrease Warner’s ability to make plays and get the ball downfield.

Overall, I think dick Dick LeBeau’s outfit will be more prepared than the Eagles were. It has recently been discovered that defensive coordinator Jim Johnson has metastatic cancer (skin) to the spine, which has limited his involvement. This might be in part responsible for the Cards fast start against the Eagles. The toughness, the balance of offense and defense of the Steelers, as well as the push up front from the three lineman plus one linebacker will be too much for the Cards.

Too tough. Too balanced. Too experienced. Plus, as someone who grew up in St. Louis, I know better than anyone that the Cardinals are born losers. After all, this is still Bill Bidwell’s team. There has never been anything “super” about that man. Meanwhile, Mr. Rooney and his Steelers have five Lombardi trophies. The Steelers win this one decisively.

Remember the name Casey Hampton.

Oh, remember the name Santonio Holmes, too. Very underrated player.

(Adam’s rebuttal after the jump…)

Arrowhead Adam: Dearest Johnny Boy,

Casey Hampton. Yeah, sure, that’s a nice thought and all. Throwing something out there a little different to keep me on my toes. I’ll get to that, but first off let’s talk Larry Fitzgerald.

I know you don’t like his ‘do, but why do you have to be such a hater? Fitzgerald will be the best player on the field at the New Sombrero today hands down. In fact, he’s the best player in the entire NFL right now. This year, yeah, to me that’s irrefutable. It’s ironic that 10 years ago he was a ballboy for the Minnesota Vikings. Why? Because he has the homerun and jump ball abilities of Randy Moss, and the hands, route-running ability and work ethic of Chris Carter. He is the ultimate receiver.

The Steelers won’t have an answer for him. The Eagles have a better all-around secondary, to me it’s not even a debate. Their corners are way better. Sure, Troy Polamalu’s phenomonal, but he won’t be the guy sticking Fitz. That will be Ike Taylor. If Tina Turner’s watching the broadcast tonight, she’ll hear the words “Ike” and “beat” in the same sentence so often she’ll start ducking. Don’t try to act like Jim Johnson wasn’t prepared either. He’s a pro’s pro — he was prepared.

Dick LeBeau is going to make the same mistake Johnson made by sending the house at Kurt Warner. Warner gets rid of the ball faster than any quarterback in the league. With Anquan Boldin and Fitzgerald damn near impossible to hold up at the line, and Steve Breaston often in the slot, Warner’s going to be able to get the ball off when the Steelers blitz. You’re right about Hampton in one way; for the Pittsburgh defense to be successful, the Steelers need to send only a four-, maybe five-man rush on most plays. They’ll need their outside backers and safeties to help contain Boldin, Breaston and Fitz. Problem is that while the Cardinals’ offensive line struggles a bit with run blocking, they are terrific pass blockers. I don’t see any way the Steelers can stop the Cardinals’ passing attack, and in particular Fitz. Todd Haley and his offense get the best of the old man and his Steel Curtain today.

By the way, don’t you remember how “Casey at the Bat” ends? Probably not. You’re old and have alzheimers and that’s why you think the Steelers are going to win. Do you think it’s still the 70s or something? Anyway, here’s the end of the poem…

But there is no joy in Mudville Pittsburgh — mighty Casey has struck out.

You were alive the day that thing was first published, you should’ve remembered that. That being said, I expect the same outcome tomorrow. Adrian Wilson will be the safety everybody’s talking about Monday, after he leads that young, opportunistic secondary in picking apart Ben Roethlisberger.

Here are my two names for you to remember:

Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie.

Steve Breaston.

They’re the reason we’ll remember more of the commercials than Santonio Holmes after the Big Game commences.

For more Super Bowl coverage head over and check out official, up-to-date game previews from Nice Pick, Cowher and Raising Arizona.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,
Comments
Comments have been disabled for this post.
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Oh I guess we will see...

The Belichick breakdown of what he would gameplan was sweet...good stuff...

I think it was Golic and some other douche actually. Skip Bayless probably has no credibility whatsoever.

Well, First and 10...I'm guessing Skip Bayless was involved?

Fair enough. Sometimes they say stuff that is just plain ludicrous and asinine. For example, they were debating on 1st and 10 whether this Steelers D was better than the 00 Ravens. They picked the Steelers! How quickly they forget in the football media. Very short term memory, but that is their job I guess. The Ravens that year won the Super Bowl with Trent Dilfer at QB. Enough said.

I don't think they all do by any means. Chris Mortenson, well, there's a glaring example of pushing stories over concrete facts. And it does happen. But from my experiences it's not always like that. FOX, for example, has never pushed an opinion on me. Not one time. I know I'm not exactly Chris Mortenson, but I know some people here and there. I don't think it's always like that. But, yeah, again it does happen.

Everyone who gets paid to analyze football loses their credibility immediately when they sign their contract. I doubt they even believe half the shit the producers make them say. On that note, how about Herm getting hired by ESPN as an analyst? Maybe he will squint at the teleprompter like he used to stare and squint at the scoreboard hahahaha

B-Dawk is the best leader and tackler out of all the safeties, and possibly the best player at stripping quarterbacks in the league. Another great blitzing safety. This final four featured some fine safeties.

I think Troy Polamalu is one of the best players in the league, but he is not the best player on the field today. That actually makes me chuckle a bit the way Fitz has been playing. What records has Tasmanian Troy broken these playoffs?

Woody, you know me better than that. When have I ever ceded anything? I'm the kinda guy who feels he can take a losing argument and win every time. Got that Johnnie Cochran in me, I guess :)

Right now, in this postseason, and looking back at what he did during the regular season, YES, he has unequivocally been the best player in the NFL this season.

Most commentators, schmost commentators. I know a thing or two about the NFL myself, and I'm rolling with Fitz. His production was better than Randy's and he's proved he can perform at his highest level in the playoffs time and time again. Until Andre Johnson has that opportunity, unfortunately, he can't really be considered the guy.

Fitzgerald has risen his play to an all-time high for receivers in the playoffs. Jerry Rice never even did this sh**. Last year, remember when Randy Moss completely went ghost in the playoffs? I do. I'll take Fitz any day of the week.

And I can understand you not wanting me to be right. But no matter what I'm already right on Haley and the Case for Crabtree. Haley's proven he is the hottest young coordinator in the game for a reason, and Fitz and Boldin have proven that a great set of receivers can take their team to the Big Game. The Cardinals have already took care of all that for me. A win would just be the icing on top to silence all the naysayers.

So you know...Baldinger just commented on NFLN that "I dont think there is any question![Troy is the best player in the game today]"

But he is kind of a tool

Yes, Dr. Paine, I did mean that, best SS...thanks for keeping me honest lol.

Wilson is very under-rated...and a great dude too

I dont like the Steelers, I want Cardinals...sir...

But, even with all these numbers you talk about, every time I hear it brought up in any conversation about best WR in the league most commentators still have Andre Johnson and Moss and so on rated higher...Johnson is like the same man but without the haircut (For the Old Man). If Johnson played in Fitz place I have a hard time believing you wouldnt see similar results...with Warner, OL, Halye, so on...

But your proclamation was that he was the best player in the league period...So I am willing to cede my claim about best WR if you will cede your best player overall... :)

I agree the Steelers corners are over-rated...Part of me wants the Cardinals to kill them but the other part doesn't want Adam to be able to say he was right...lol

Ed had 10 picks in 7 games (including Miami Wild Card), a forced fumble, and two touchdowns. Who else even grazes that production?

Woody,

How is Fitz not the best receiver in the league right now? He had like 100 catches and 1400 yards despite playing with two other 1,000-yard receivers and shattered Jerry Rice's playoff record in three games. If he's not the best, than who is? Show me a more complete, more talented, more productive receiver this season and postseason. You can't.

Keep drinking that Steelers Kool-Aid. Yuck.

It just depends. The best blitzing safety in the league, that's Adrian Wilson. He's also the most underrated player in the NFL. All three are in the conversation as far as I'm concerned. Ed Reed's clock is ticking, too. He's not undisputed.

BTW I hope you mean Troy is the best SS in the game, not the best safety overall. That would be Ed Reed

I'm with you Adam. The Steelers corners are overrated and only have to cover for 1-2 seconds normally prior to a sack or incomplete pass. Troy is a beast, but he's more of an opportunistic run around safety. He's not a ball hawk like my boy Ed Reed. I'm thinking Warner shreds that zone blitz, Q has a big game after the whole media circus, and Fitz will remain uncoverable. Cards 27-20

All I could read was your first paragraph Adam and couldn't take it any more...ridiculous to say Fitz is best player in the league, he is not even the best WR in the NFL today, Cards are just gelling....I don't care how much you deny it...

And he will be playing against two players best at their position in the NFL Troy and Hampton (best NT not DT)....sooooo