Tough question. I think you go with Brodie Croyle when he returns, because theoretically he gives the Chiefs the best chance to win long term. Damon Huard gives us the better chance right now, but a 35-year-old career clipboard holder shouldn’t be anything more than a stop-gap option at this point. Well, that and Tyler Thigpen repellent. Additionally, we don’t need to delay our Brodie evaluation another year. For better or worse, we need to decide on him by the end of this season.
Should Brodie or Damon start when Brodie returns?